Keep an eye on this Stephin Merritt dude. This song is pretty good. Sounds like it was recorded in a basement in the early-to-mid 90s. Looks like it'll show up in a collection by the guy, called Obscurities (1994-99), out August 23 on Merge Records (nice one, Stephin!).
Stephin Merritt, “Forever and a Day”
Here are other songs that are also called “Forever and a Day”
Lionel Richie, “Forever and a Day”
Jewel, “Forever and a Day, Always”
Silverstein, “Forever and a Day”
Kelly Rowland, “Forever and a Day”
Fragma ,”Forever and a Day”
The Offspring, “Forever and a Day”
Her Space Holiday, “Forever and a Day”
Gary Allan, “Forever and a Day”